AG
ASSURED GUARANTY LTD (AGO)·Q1 2017 Earnings Summary
Executive Summary
- Strong Q1 2017 driven by MBIA UK acquisition and loss mitigation; GAAP EPS $2.49 and operating EPS $2.14, with total revenues $527M, up sequentially and year over year .
- Significant one-time items: $58M bargain purchase gain and $73M commutation gain; fair value gains on credit derivatives of $54M; these boosted results and raise volatility considerations .
- New business momentum: PVP $99M and GWP $111M, highest since 2010, with $4.69B gross par written (U.S. municipal and UK infrastructure) .
- Management expects 2017 share repurchases to exceed 2016, “closer to the $500M+ levels of 2014 and 2015,” a potential stock-support catalyst given capital strength (claims-paying resources $12.09B) .
- Puerto Rico: increased expected losses ($47M economic loss) offset by litigation settlement benefits; Title III filing sets up prolonged litigation path; company is assertively defending creditor rights .
What Went Well and What Went Wrong
What Went Well
- Record book value metrics and strong operating profit: “Operating income of $273M… non-GAAP operating shareholders’ equity per share $52.51 and… adjusted book value per share $71.51 reached new highs” .
- International momentum: “We are clearly seeing renewed demand for our guaranty in the U.K.… our U.K. office issued a guaranty for an oversubscribed GBP 261M 20-year… St. James Hospital in Leeds. This was our largest U.K. transaction since 2008” .
- U.S. municipal leadership and secondary demand: “Assured Guaranty increased its share of the total insured par sold to 57%… $711M of secondary market par… nearly double [prior year]” .
What Went Wrong
- Loss development tied to Puerto Rico: Q1 economic loss of $47M “primarily related to an increase in Puerto Rico expected losses,” partially offset by litigation settlement benefits .
- Lower net earned premiums vs prior periods due to fewer refundings/terminations: $164M in Q1 2017 vs $236M in Q4 2016 and $183M in Q1 2016; accelerated premiums fell to $58M vs $89M in Q1 2016 .
- Title III uncertainty increases duration and litigation intensity: “The Commonwealth… filed for protection under Title III… We promptly filed an adversarial complaint… [this] locks you in to a very long series [like bankruptcy]” .
Financial Results
Segment-like revenue components (composition):
Key KPIs and balance metrics:
Guidance Changes
No formal revenue/margin/OpEx guidance was provided in Q1 2017 materials .
Earnings Call Themes & Trends
Management Commentary
- Dominic Frederico, CEO: “Assured Guaranty began 2017 with a truly great first quarter… Operating income of $273M… PVP totaled $99M, the highest quarterly PVP since Q4 2010” .
- On UK momentum: “We are clearly seeing renewed demand for our guaranty in the U.K.… our largest U.K. transaction since 2008” .
- On Puerto Rico: “We promptly filed an adversarial complaint… let’s bring it on… we are confident in our rights… having a constitutional judge is really positive” .
- Robert Bailenson, CFO: “The MBIA UK acquisition… generated approximately $61M of operating income or $0.48 per share… increase in net investment income… nonrecurring accretion related to the Zohar II notes used to fund the MBIA UK acquisition” .
- On buybacks: “We expect to repurchase more common shares in 2017 than we did last year, closer to the $500M+ levels of 2014 and 2015” .
Q&A Highlights
- Puerto Rico Title III and creditor rights: Management emphasized constitutional priority and readiness for litigation; sees federal judge oversight as constructive for enforcing lawful priorities .
- PREPA RSA: “We’re positive on the RSA… it resolves roughly $9B of exposure… expecting effectiveness towards the end of this year” (subject to certifications) .
- EPS trajectory question: Caution on forecasting; Q1 benefited from MBIA UK acquisition and reassumption; timing of future deals uncertain .
- M&A outlook: Active dialogues; potential for consolidation of legacy guarantors as challenges (e.g., Puerto Rico) stress portfolios; tax reform could catalyze activity by diminishing NOL value .
Estimates Context
- Wall Street consensus via S&P Global for Q1 2017 EPS and revenue was unavailable due to retrieval limits at the time of this analysis. As a result, we cannot benchmark the quarter to consensus and cannot designate formal beats/misses. Given large non-recurring gains (bargain purchase, commutation) and fair value volatility, analysts may adjust models to emphasize non-GAAP operating trends and new business momentum .
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Q1 quality and momentum: Strong operating earnings with record book values and robust new business production; watch mix effects and one-time items for sustainability .
- Capital return likely stepping up: Management’s >$500M 2017 buyback commentary, underpinned by $12.09B claims-paying resources, supports equity accretion and may provide stock support .
- International diversification is real: UK infrastructure pipeline and MBIA UK acquisition broaden exposures and PVP, reducing reliance on U.S. refundings .
- Puerto Rico path is litigious but bounded: Title III raises duration risk; company is assertively defending creditor rights; expect ongoing reserve and legal developments .
- Earnings drivers are volatile: Fair value movements, bargain purchase gains, and commutation effects materially swing GAAP results; focus on operating EPS and PVP trend for core performance .
- Secondary market demand is a tailwind: Rising insured secondary par volumes indicate growing institutional appreciation of wraps amid rate normalization .
- Watch effective tax rate: Lower operating tax rate (mix and non-taxable gains) lifted EPS; rate normalization could temper EPS absent further one-time items .